Top 5 Mistakes to Avoid When Buying a Wedding Ring

We’ve said it once and we’ll say it again - jewellery is personal. But when it comes to wedding rings, it’s on a whole other level. This is the ring you’ll be wearing forever. It’s not just a sparkle on your finger, it’s a symbol of your story, your style, and your standards. And yet, in the whirlwind of wedding planning, so many people make mistakes that can be easily avoided with a little insider knowledge.

So today, we’re letting you in on the Top 5 Mistakes to Avoid When Buying a Wedding Ring - consider this your chic little cheat sheet. Whether you're a minimalist or the most glamorous bride-to-be, these tips will help you find the wedding ring that truly lives up to the moment.

1. Prioritising Trends Over Timelessness

Let’s be honest - we all love a good trend. They’ve all had their moment. But your wedding ring isn’t a pair of shoes. It’s not something you’ll switch out next season when you’ve moved on. One of the biggest mistakes we see are brides choosing a ring because it’s “so right now.” Where what you actually want is forever. That doesn’t mean boring. But think of it the way you’d think of a timeless piece. Elegant and something you’ll always gravitate towards.

It should feel like you. If chunky gold, double enhancer bands, mixed metals, or even coloured diamonds are your thing - then go for it. But don’t choose just because it’s the current trend and everyone else is wearing it. The decision should be one that means something to you. 

Expert Tip: Choose a ring that reflects you, not just what’s filling up your Instagram/Pinterest board. Trust your instinct and if you're unsure, go for classic. Beautiful diamond bands with clean lines and quality craftsmanship never go out of style. You’ll thank yourself in ten, twenty, thirty, forty or fifty years (and every day in between).

2. Forgetting Your Future

We get it, it's not glamorous to talk about how your wedding ring will wear in the future and its practicality. But, imagine spending thousands on a divine diamond wedding ring only to realise you can barely wear it. Tragic.

Your wedding ring should integrate into your life and feel effortless on the hand, not interrupt it. Consider your daily comfort by thoughtfully choosing your band finish (such as a comfort fit ring) and the band width so it will feel seamless and comfortable. Also think about how far along the band the diamonds will go (¼, ½, ¾ or full) as this choice can affect resizing in the future. These are questions you must consider - or risk your wedding ring living in a jewellery box rather than on your hand where it belongs.

Expert Tip: Consider designs that offer maximum comfort and flexibility with resizing for the future (such as wedding ring designs with diamonds halfway along the band). You can still have all the sparkle you deserve if you’re strategic about it. 

3. Not Thinking About How It Pairs with Your Engagement Ring

This one is so often overlooked. You’ve said yes to the engagement ring of your dreams but now the wedding band needs to co-exist with it. They need harmonise with each other to speak the same language. If your engagement ring has a lower setting or a unique and detailed shape, you may need a curved or more shaped wedding band. Don’t assume a straight wedding band will just slide in and work seamlessly unless it's designed this way. 

Expert Tip: At JANAI, your ring pairing with your engagement ring isn’t something you need to worry about - as all of our wedding bands will be designed to sit flush with your engagement ring. When you’re designing your rings we can discuss future wedding rings and you can even try styles together. Having both rings designed together from the beginning. It’s the ultimate expression of cohesion and class.

4. Compromising to Save for the Wedding

We understand. Weddings are expensive. But please don’t sacrifice the quality or the style of the one thing from your wedding that you’ll keep forever and wear every single day. Cutting corners on your ring might feel sensible in the moment, but it will just lead to future regret. This is an investment. Not just in beauty, but in longevity. 

Expert Tip: If budget is a concern, go for smaller or lab diamonds for something quality but at a more affordable price point. A diamond or gold band will always be chic. You can always invest in eternity diamond bands or upgrades for anniversaries down the line. 

5. Ignoring the Sentimental Side

Amid all the talk of how many diamonds, carat weights, band metal types and millimetres, don’t forget what this ring actually means. It’s not just an accessory. It’s the physical form of your promises to each other. Some couples get so caught up in the technicalities that they forget to bring heart into the process of designing their wedding rings. Choose designs inspired by your love story, these small details turn a beautiful ring into your ring.

Expert Tip: Take a moment during the design process to think about what you want your rings to symbolise and what is truly meaningful to you. A design you’ve always dreamed of? Bold diamonds to feel glamorous or like a princess? a meaningful detail from an heirloom design? These are the special details that make your ring uniquely yours.

Final Thoughts

Your wedding ring in Melbourne is one of the few things from your big day that you’ll carry with you everywhere, always. It deserves time, thought, and beauty. Don’t rush it. Don’t settle. And definitely don’t let other people’s opinions cloud your vision. Because the ring isn’t just the end of your wedding planning checklist. It’s the beginning of something much more beautiful.

To craft the wedding ring of your dreams, fill out your details to request your appointment below and create the diamond ring you deserve with JANAI